Checked by The Things To Do In Fernandina Beach editorial desk.
Fernandina Beach has five restaurants that count as a proper evening out, and between them they cover a small enough range that choosing is genuinely a matter of what kind of night you want rather than which is best.
All five take bookings and all five need them at weekends in season. Two are within four blocks of Centre Street, one is on the eastern edge of downtown, and one is fifteen minutes south in the resort corridor.
How this list is put together: Restaurants where you would book a table, dress a notch up, and expect the evening to take two hours.
Fine Dining in Fernandina Beach
-
1
Burlingame Restaurant
The island's top-bracket kitchen, on South 5th. A changing menu and a real wine list. Book well ahead.
Burlingame guide → -
2
España Restaurant & Tapas
Spanish tapas and paella in a house on South 4th. The most atmospheric of the five, and the best for a table of four or more.
España guide → -
3
David's Restaurant & Lounge
Seasonal Southern cooking with a lounge attached, on Ash Street. The long-running special-occasion choice.
David's guide → -
4
The Patio at 5th & Ash
Bistro scale and local seafood on a quiet corner — the price band just below the top.
The Patio guide → -
5
Lagniappe
The south end's best table, on First Coast Highway. New American with a New Orleans lean, fifteen minutes from downtown.
Lagniappe guide →
Fine Dining in Fernandina Beach: FAQ
What is the best restaurant in Fernandina Beach?
For a serious dinner, Burlingame on South 5th Street is the one most often named, with Lagniappe the equivalent on the south end of the island. España is the pick for atmosphere and for larger tables.
Do Fernandina Beach restaurants require reservations?
The five on this page effectively do at weekends and in season. Most of the rest of the island's dining is walk-in.
Is there fine dining near the Omni or Ritz-Carlton?
Lagniappe on First Coast Highway is the south end's own destination restaurant — about ten minutes from the resort corridor and a good deal closer than downtown.
How expensive is dinner in Fernandina Beach?
The fine-dining rooms sit in the island's top bracket; the bistro tier below them costs meaningfully less; and the counters and pizza shops will feed a family for the price of one fine-dining main.